ADVERTISEMENT

The 5 Most Effective Natural Sleep Supplements In 2022

Discover which natural ingredients can help improve the quality of your sleep, which supplements are worth buying and which ones to watch out for.

Linda is our resident health and wellness editor. As a long time health and nutrition enthusiast, she spends her time researching scientific studies and keeping up with the latest health and wellness trends to provide top nutrition tips.

Are you plagued with exhaustion day in and day out? You might be one of the several million Britons suffering from sleep deprivation. Although sleep deprivation is common, many people who suffer from it don’t realise that sleep deprivation is a serious health concern that can have dire impacts on our health. In this article, we will discuss some of the tell-tale signs of sleep deprivation, which natural ingredients can help and which supplements are worth investing in to improve the quality of your sleep.

There are many reasons why people struggle to get a good night's sleep, including lifestyle factors like work and family obligations, stress, illness, age, and more. The main symptoms of sleep deprivation are feeling very tired during the hours you’re awake, struggling to focus, fluctuating mood, headaches and more.

While many people experience poor sleep at some point in their lives, chronic sleep deprivation can lead to dangerous health complications. When left untreated, sleep deprivation can increase the risk of diabetes, high blood pressure, obesity, stroke and heart failure.

Those that struggle with chronic sleep deprivation often turn to over the counter or prescription drugs to mend their sleeplessness. However, these can be dangerous when taken long term and some prescription drugs can be addictive. This is why many people are opting to try natural treatments to remedy their sleep deprivation in a safe and healthy manner.

Which ingredients help to improve sleep?

  • 5-HTP
  • 5-HTP helps to boost serotonin levels in the brain, which in turn is converted into melatonin. Melatonin is the hormone in our body that is responsible for regulating our sleep cycle. 5-HTP has become one of the most popular supplements to help relieve sleeplessness, pain, stress and anxiety, and more.

  • B Vitamins
  • Studies have found that B Vitamins, particularly Vitamin B6, Vitamin B12 and Vitamin B9, can significantly help to improve sleep quality. These B vitamins aid in regulating tryptophan, which helps to produce melatonin.

  • Hops
  • Research has shown that hops can increase the activity of GABA (a neurotransmitter) and it can help to decrease sleep latency and anxiety.

  • Montmorency Cherry
  • Montmorency Cherry provides a natural source of melatonin, helping to promote a more restful sleep.

  • Zinc
  • Zinc has been shown to increase the quality of sleep, while also promoting calmness.

  • Chamomile
  • Chamomile supports better sleep by promoting relaxation. It contains compounds that bind to GABA, which makes us feel more sleepy.

At Trustworthy Reviews, we've analyzed some of the top-selling sleep supplements on the market to help guide you in the right direction. We'll show you what to look for and what to avoid in a high-quality supplement, plus, we share our top 5 picks of the year.

What should I look for in my supplement?

Look for a supplement with 5-HTP & Montmorency Cherry

5-HTP is one of the best ingredients that you can find in sleep supplements. This is because it is a precursor to melatonin - it turns into melatonin, which then induces sleep. Studies have found that taking 100mg of high quality 5-HTP per day can help to improve sleep. Montmorency Cherry is also an extremely safe source of natural melatonin. This is far safer than buying a pure melatonin supplement (which are now illegal in the UK and prescription only due to safety concerns.)

Choose a supplement with multiple ‘sleep inducing’ ingredients

Many sleep supplements only contain 1 or 2 ingredients in their formulas (for example, many only contain 5-HTP). However, there are numerous ingredients that help to promote restful sleep and they function differently. Some ingredients help by stimulating the activity of GABA while others turn into melatonin. Finding a supplement that delivers several ingredients that provide different benefits will likely yield better results. Some other great ingredients to look out for include lemon balm, magnesium & hops extract.

Money-back guarantee.

Look for a product that offers a money-back guarantee on all purchases. Offering a money-back guarantee is a sign that a company is confident in the quality of the products they are providing.


What should I avoid?

Pure Melatonin Supplements

5-HTP is a much safer alternative to melatonin and delivers excellent results. There are many risks and unpleasant side effects associated with taking melatonin directly, which is why it’s banned from being sold in the UK and several other countries in the world now.

Anywhere currently directly selling melatonin supplements in the UK without a prescription is doing so illegally (and therefore the product quality should be doubted). The most common side effects include headaches, dizziness, drowsiness and nausea. Some less common symptoms include changes in mood (some people experience anxiety and depression), low blood pressure, tremors, disorientation, abdominal discomfort, and more.

Low potency products

When choosing a quality sleep supplement, it’s important to choose a potent formula. Make sure that the supplement you choose contains adequate dosages for the ingredients in their product. Many brands pack their formulas with a great lineup of ingredients, but they don’t put the recommended dosage. Thus, if your supplement is not potent enough, you will likely not see the results you are hoping to see.

Beware of online reviews (especially on Amazon).

Before purchasing any product, one of the first things we do when researching it is check its online reviews. Unfortunately, these are not always a trustworthy way to measure the quality and effectiveness of a product. Companies often pay for reviews on popular online retailers, like Amazon, to try and trick their way to a five star rating. While you should definitely consult these reviews before purchasing, do your own research as well.

How we evaluated the top 5

Over the last several years, scientists and researchers have discovered that numerous natural ingredients can have a positive effect on the quality of our sleep. More and more, people are beginning to turn to natural supplements to improve their sleep patterns, which has led to sleep supplements becoming one of the most in-demand products on the supplement market today, with lots of options to choose from. While this means you have many options to consider when choosing your supplement, it can also be difficult to narrow down which ones will deliver the best results.

We researched the top rated sleep supplements on the internet to find the best ones available on the market and evaluated them based on product quality, customer service, and pricing.

Here are our top 5 Sleep supplement picks for 2022.

9.7 / 10 963 Votes TOTAL RANKING

A+

Overall Grade
INGREDIENT SAFETY
100%
PROJECTED EFFECTIVENESS
97%
VALUE
93%
RETURN POLICY
98%
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION
98%

10

/10

9.7

/10

9.3

/10

9.7

/10

9.8

/10

PROS

  • Contains the recommended 100mg of 5-HTP
  • Potent doses of each ingredient in their formula
  • Contains 11 ingredients that are studied and proven to help promote restful sleep, including: B vitamins, Zinc, Magnesium, Chamomile Extract, Hops Extract, Montmorency Cherry, Lemon Balm and California Poppy Extract
  • GMO-free & vegan-friendly
  • Money-back guarantee.
  • Recommended by healthcare professionals.
  • Made in the UK.

CONS

  • Only available online

  • Express delivery is only available in the UK and certain European countries

The Bottom Line

Coming in at the top is Hey Nutrition’s Night Time Complex. Most sleep supplements on the market only contain 1-3 ingredients, whereas Hey Nutrition’s sleep supplement includes numerous ingredients, making it a overall more powerful and well-rounded sleep product. Their sleep supplement contains all of the ingredients we look for in a great sleep supplement, including 5-HTP, Montmorency Cherry, Magnesium, Hops Extract and more.

Each ingredient in their product is delivered in potent doses (for example 100mg of 5-HTP and 400mg of Chamomile) in order to achieve the best results. Their product is vegan friendly and free of gluten, GMOs and allergens, so it is suitable for everyone.

Hey Nutrition really did a good job with this product, you can tell they really did their research when formulating it and therefore clearly have the most effective sleep product on the market.

Hey Nutrition offers a 60-day money back guarantee on all purchases and reviews consistently praise their great customer service, so this really is a no-brainer and entirely risk-free to try! Moreover, out of all the other products we have reviewed, Hey Nutrition has the most 5* reviews on Trustpilot, a trusted source for reviews.

2. Love Life 5-HTP Complex

7.9 /10 412 Votes TOTAL RANKING

B

Overall Grade
INGREDIENT SAFETY
91%
PROJECTED EFFECTIVENESS
81%
VALUE
90%
RETURN POLICY
78%
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION
83%

9.1

/10

8.1

/10

9.0

/10

7.8

/10

8.3

/10

PROS

  • Contains 100mg of 5-HTP
  • Includes two additional ingredients: Schisandra Powder and Reishi Mushroom Extract
  • -Non-GMO and Vegan friendly

CONS

  • Does not contain GABA stimulating ingredients
  • More research needs to be done on the effectiveness of Schisandra Powder and Reishi Mushroom Extract as sleep aids
  • No money-back guarantee
  • Does not contain any additional ingredients such as Montmorency Cherry

The Bottom Line

Love Life Supplements is a lesser known brand in the UK, but they have a slew of products in their range, including their 5-HTP Complex. When we are reviewing supplements, we always look for complexes as these formulas combine a multitude of ingredients to create one powerful product.

The 5-HTP complex is a unique mix of three active ingredients: 5-HTP (100mg per serving), Schisandra Powder and Reishi Mushroom Extract. Although they include 5-HTP in their complex, we feel like they could have chosen better ingredients to go alongside it. While Schisandra Powder and Reishi Mushroom Extract have been shown to provide some help, there is still a lot of work to be done on the two ingredients in order to prove their effectiveness and so we recommend waiting for further research.

3. Vitl Sweet Sleep

7.8 /10 269 Votes TOTAL RANKING

B

Overall Grade
INGREDIENT SAFETY
90%
PROJECTED EFFECTIVENESS
85%
VALUE
83%
RETURN POLICY
78%
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION
87%

9.0

/10

8.5

/10

8.3

/10

7.8

/10

8.7

/10

PROS

  • Includes beneficial ingredients, including: Lemon Balm, L-Theanine & Vitamin B6
  • Vegan-friendly

CONS

  • Does not contain 5-HTP
  • No money-back guarantee

The Bottom Line

Vitl is an interesting health and wellness company that not only creates supplements, but also at home DNA blood testing kits. Out of all the products we have reviewed, their sleep supplement has one of the larger ingredients lists.

Vitl’s sleep supplement includes 7 ingredients to help you get a good night's sleep, however they are missing one crucial ingredient - 5-HTP.

We were impressed to see so many great natural ingredients in their formula, however, 5-HTP appears to have been left off the ingredients list. In our opinion 5-HTP is the best/safest way to get your melatonin dose in the UK, and so we would recommend a supplement containing this over this one.

4. Pukka Night Time

7.3 /10 301 Votes TOTAL RANKING

B-

Overall Grade
INGREDIENT SAFETY
90%
PROJECTED EFFECTIVENESS
82%
VALUE
82%
RETURN POLICY
78%
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION
95%

9.0

/10

8.2

/10

8.2

/10

7.8

/10

8.5

/10

PROS

  • Formulated with Ashwagandha Root Powder, Valerian Root Powder and Gotu Kola Aerial Root Powder
  • Reasonably priced
  • Organic and non-GMO
  • Vegetarian and vegan friendly

CONS

  • Does not contain 5-HTP
  • Limited supply in each bottle

The Bottom Line

Pukka has introduced a sleep supplement with three sleep inducing ingredients: Ashwagandha Root Powder, Valerian Root Powder and Gotu Kola Aerial Root Powder. Although these ingredients help to promote restful sleep, our opinion is that they are better positioned to support calmness and help to relieve stress.

We believe their product would be more effective if it also contained 5-HTP, Montmorency Cherry along with some other ingredients such as Hops Extract. Moreover, each bottle contains just 30 capsules and the recommended daily serving is 2 capsules per day. This means that 1 bottle would only last you two weeks, which is a inconvenient.

5. Nutravita 5-HTP

7.3 /10 207 Votes TOTAL RANKING

C

Overall Grade
INGREDIENT SAFETY
79%
PROJECTED EFFECTIVENESS
70%
VALUE
76%
RETURN POLICY
78%
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION
70%

7.9

/10

7.0

/10

7.6

/10

7.8

/10

7.0

/10

PROS

  • Vegan-friendly, GMO-free, no synthetic fillers and binders

CONS

  • Only contains 50mg of 5-HTP
  • Does not contain any GABA stimulating ingredients
  • No money-back guarantee
  • Does not include any additional ingredients

The Bottom Line

Nutravita is consistently one of the most popular choices among UK consumers when it comes to supplements. They have a large range of products and they offer good customer service too.

Yet, their 5-HTP product is lacking. It only contains 50mg of 5-HTP from griffonia extract per serving (although their marketing is deceiving and makes it seem as though it's 400mg). This is a small dose of the ingredient, and, it is notably the only sleep aid ingredient present in the product. The other products in our top 5 list include a superior and more comprehensive list of ingredients, which is why Nutravita’s 5-HTP has come in 5th place on our list.

Final Thoughts

The Bottom Line

When it comes to choosing a supplement to improve sleep and rest, it is essential to choose a product that is made with high quality ingredients that are clinically studied and delivered in potent doses.

After searching the internet to find the best sleep products and evaluating them based on their customer service, ingredients and pricing, we believe Hey Nutrition Night Time Complex is the best on the market.

Hey Nutrition provides a 100% satisfaction guarantee - or your money back.

Click Here To Get Hey Nutrition's Night Time Complex

CITATIONS

1. https://europepmc.org/article/med/9630738

2. https://academic.oup.com/cdn/article/5/Supplement_2/372/6293013?login=true

3. https://akjournals.com/view/journals/036/99/2/article-p133.xml

4. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0037290

5. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0965229917302601.

6. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22476977/